A homemade feed's smell does not establish its maturity or nutrient value. Keep unfinished mixtures away from indoor pots and use a more controlled feeding method.
A homemade feed needs more than a smell test
No smell, a sour smell and a strong odor do not each map neatly to a safe or finished product. Ingredients, storage and the composting process matter. A claim attributed to an experienced grower is not a substitute for a usable method.
Do not add sugar to solve everything
Extra sugar or fragrant peel does not establish a balanced nutrient composition or appropriate hygiene. An active mixture should not be treated as ready for roots merely because an arbitrary storage period has passed.
Use the right process and destination
Follow guidance for a managed composting system and dispose of unsuitable ingredients appropriately. Keep uncontrolled mixtures out of indoor pots. For routine feeding, choose a suitable labeled product only where the plant needs nutrients, and continue checking light, root moisture and drainage.












Related reading: Homemade Fertilizer Odors: Composting Needs Attention.