A color change in water is not enough to authenticate saffron. Keep the source and labeling in view rather than relying on a single home test.
What saffron is
Saffron consists of the stigmas of Crocus sativus. That botanical identity matters more than a seller's use of a red-flower common name. Safflower and other similarly named materials should not be treated as interchangeable with saffron.
Limits of home checks
A water-color test, a smell comparison or an oil mark on paper cannot by itself establish a product's identity or purity. Keep the supplier information and labeling with the product rather than treating one visual test as proof.
For gardeners
Buy clearly labeled Crocus sativus corms from a specialist source if you want to grow the plant. Do not identify an unfamiliar autumn-flowering bulb for use in food from a common name or one photograph.




Related reading: Growing Saffron Crocus in Containers.