Orange peel can go through suitable composting, but a homemade soak is not a precise fertilizer or soil treatment. Keep raw residues separate from routine pot watering.
Peel and plant nutrition are different topics
Orange peel contains organic material, but that does not make a short soak a balanced fertilizer. The amount available to a plant is unmeasured, and an acidic smell does not predict a useful change in the growing medium.
Do not mask pot problems
A persistent smell from a container needs an inspection of stagnant water, damaged roots and decaying material. Adding fragrant peel does not repair drainage. Likewise, a homemade soak is not a dependable substitute for identifying a pest.
Use suitable composting
Follow guidance for a managed composting system when handling appropriate peel scraps. Keep fresh residues out of a routine indoor watering cycle. For plants needing a particular pH or nutrient supply, choose an appropriate tested method and follow its instructions.


Related reading: Orange Peel Water: Plant Care Claims to Reconsider.